Simon might have had doubts or skepticism about Lucie Jones, a nervous singer, but her audition performance of a Whitney Houston song was so impressive that it stunned him, possibly changing his initial perception of her.
This scenario aligns with many moments on these talent shows, where contestants surprise the judges with their talent despite initial reservations. It’s not uncommon for nervous or seemingly unassuming performers to deliver astonishing auditions that leave a lasting impact.
If this is a scene from a show or a specific event, it might have been a standout moment in the series. Such instances often demonstrate the power of an unexpected and exceptional talent breaking through initial skepticism.